Difficult Conversations Are Career Moments

What a polite yes can conceal about authority, responsibility and the work no one has chosen to stop.

Imagine the end of a cross-functional leadership meeting. A senior stakeholder wants a major project milestone brought forward. The request makes sense from where that stakeholder sits: The business needs speed. Around the table, people nod. Nobody wants to be the person who slows things down just as the meeting is coming to a close.

The woman leading the programme can already see the difficulty. Her team is stretched. Two functions have competing priorities, and the earlier date will affect work that has already been promised elsewhere. She is three months into her role, still getting to know the people around the table and the decisions they are prepared to make. She wants to establish herself as someone who delivers.

So she says what capable, committed people often say: “We'll make it work.”

The meeting ends on a positive note. Afterwards come the calls, the revised plans, the favours requested from colleagues and perhaps a few tasks she quietly takes back onto her own desk. The deadline might even be met. Yet nobody has agreed which other work will stop, which risk is acceptable or who is responsible for the trade-off. What looked like alignment was, in part, an unresolved decision.

The more difficult contribution would have been to say, while everyone was still in the room: “We can bring this forward. To do that, we need to decide what moves out of the way. Who can make that call?”

This is why I see difficult conversations as career moments. They reveal something about how we understand our responsibility, how we use our authority and what we teach others to expect from us. Not every such conversation changes a career. But a pattern of avoiding them can quietly shape the kind of leader we become.

The hidden cost of keeping things comfortable

It would be easy to describe the first response as a lack of courage. I think that misses too much. People sometimes agree because they care about the work, want to protect a relationship or know that a direct challenge carries a cost. In international organisations, where decisions cross functions and reporting lines, the person raising a concern is not always the person with the power to resolve it. Reading the room matters; so does recognising when the room would rather not hear the answer.

Research helps explain why even experienced leaders can hesitate. In a 2024 paper, researchers found across two studies that supervisors' personal sense of power was associated with their willingness to address difficult issues directly. Having formal authority and feeling able to exercise it are not quite the same thing. The studies measured inclinations towards confrontation rather than observing every conversation in practice, but that distinction is valuable. A title does not automatically make speaking up feel safe.

There is also a practical consequence to the polite yes. When an unresolved trade-off disappears from a meeting, it does not disappear from the work. It reappears somewhere less visible: In a team member's evening, a compromised handover, a colleague's competing deadline or the leader's own growing list of things she will handle herself. The organisation may still get the result, which makes the underlying problem harder to see. Reliability is rewarded, and the habit of rescuing becomes easier to repeat.

Of course, leadership sometimes means taking on an unexpected problem without convening another committee. The issue is not whether a leader ever steps in. It is whether stepping in becomes the normal way of avoiding decisions that belong to other people, or to the group as a whole.

Why the first months in a role can make this harder

A transition adds another layer to the dilemma. An experienced woman may be entirely confident in her technical judgment and still be learning the informal expectations of a new leadership role. She is finding out who influences whom, how disagreement is received and where her mandate begins and ends. The ability that helped her earn the promotion—being the person who gets things done—can be the very habit she now needs to examine.

A systematic review of 136 studies on leadership transitions, published online in 2025, describes this period as more than learning a new set of tasks. New leaders are adjusting to a role, reshaping their leadership identity and seeking recognition from others. That does not prove they avoid difficult conversations more often than established leaders. It does help explain why one ordinary question about resources or priorities can feel unusually consequential when somebody is still establishing credibility.

The distinction between suggesting an improvement and naming a problem is revealing. A 2024 longitudinal study followed 198 people who were new to their organisations during their first eight months. Their willingness to raise concerns about existing problems increased over time, while their overall level of silence did not significantly decline. The research was about organisational newcomers, not specifically experienced executives stepping into internal promotions. Still, it reminds us that settling into a workplace does not automatically remove the calculations people make about what is safe to say.

This is also why advice such as “just be more confident” can be unhelpful. Sometimes the hesitation is personal. Sometimes it reflects an accurate reading of the politics or a real lack of decision-making authority. Often both are present. As I explored in A Leadership Title Is Not a Mandate, being accountable for an outcome is not the same as having the authority to make every decision required to achieve it.

What the conversation is actually about

Return to our meeting. At the personal level, the new leader may fear disappointing the person who appointed her or appearing insufficiently committed. At the level of her role, she is responsible for giving an honest picture of what the new deadline demands and for protecting her team's ability to do the agreed work. At the system level, priorities are competing, decision rights may be scattered across functions and the consequences of one choice will be felt elsewhere.

These are three different problems. They cannot all be solved by finding a more diplomatic sentence. A leader can prepare carefully, choose her moment and express the issue without blame. But she cannot single-handedly create the resources, authority or agreement that the organisation has not provided. When we treat every difficult conversation as a personal communication challenge, we risk asking women to become better at carrying contradictions that other people have not resolved.

What, then, would change the meeting? The leader might acknowledge the business need for speed and make the trade-off specific: Bringing this milestone forward means delaying another commitment, accepting a defined risk or adding capacity. Instead of promising the impossible and finding a private workaround, she asks the people who own those priorities to make a choice. She is not refusing responsibility. She is putting responsibility where it can be exercised.

The distinction is especially important in matrix organisations. A request can sound like an instruction while leaving no single person accountable for its consequences. A discussion that makes those consequences visible may feel less harmonious in the moment, yet it gives colleagues something useful: An honest basis for deciding, rather than a reassuring answer that everyone interprets differently.

A difficult conversation need not damage a relationship

Many leaders hesitate because they want to preserve trust. That concern deserves respect. Correcting a colleague, raising a missed commitment or disagreeing with a senior stakeholder can be uncomfortable, and there are workplaces where the response to such candour is genuinely punitive. The solution cannot simply be to ask individuals to speak more bravely while leaving those conditions untouched.

But avoiding the issue is not always the kinder choice. In a 2025 study based on interviews across three global organisations, researchers found that people often struggled to give corrective feedback because they worried about harming relationships. Whether they went ahead depended partly on the norms around them and what they had learned from previous workplaces. The conversation was not just a test of individual confidence; it was influenced by the culture in which it took place.

Other recent research suggests that difficult exchanges, handled constructively, can also support relationships. A qualitative study drawing on accounts of 166 conversations between leaders and followers found that approaches which acknowledged emotions and built shared understanding could contribute to positive relational outcomes. That is not a promise that every honest conversation will end well. It is a reminder that protecting a relationship and avoiding a necessary conversation are not always the same thing.

The aim is not to make the room uncomfortable for the sake of it. It is to make the important issue discussable while leaving people with their dignity intact. That may involve listening to concerns we had not anticipated, accepting that somebody will be disappointed or agreeing that the decision needs to be taken elsewhere. Constructive tension is useful only when it helps people see and address what is real.

Where coaching can make a difference

This is the kind of leadership situation where I find the coaching perspective especially valuable. Before practising how to phrase the difficult sentence, I would want to understand what the person is trying to protect. Is she concerned about losing trust, about being seen as difficult, or about confirming an old fear that she has not yet earned her place? Then we would look at the responsibility itself. What decision is hidden inside the request? Which part genuinely belongs to her, and which part needs to be made visible to someone else?

That reflection can change the conversation before a single word is rehearsed. It helps separate the discomfort of disappointing someone from the professional obligation to make expectations clear. It also helps a leader notice the moment when being helpful turns into taking ownership of work, risk or decisions that should be shared.

Coaching does not make an unsupportive system fair, and it should never be a way of teaching someone to tolerate unreasonable conditions more gracefully. Its value is in helping a person see her choices more clearly, understand the role she is being asked to play and prepare to act with both judgment and self-respect. That is a different ambition from simply becoming better at difficult conversations.

Imagine the meeting again. The request to bring the milestone forward has not changed. Neither have the competing priorities. What can change is the leader's response: Rather than absorbing the problem as proof that she can deliver, she makes the decision visible and invites the right people to take responsibility for it.

Authority is not the absence of tension. It is the ability to work with tension constructively.

If you are navigating a new leadership role—or noticing that you are becoming the person who quietly makes every impossible request possible—a Career Clarity Call can be a place to examine what belongs to you, what belongs to the role and what needs to be discussed with others.

Stay courageous,
Katharina

Sources

Figueroa et al. (2024). Who handles the tough talk? Supervisor sense of power and confronting difficult issues. Social and Personality Psychology Compass.

Jiang, Agolli & Harold (2025, online). Leader Role Transition: A Systematic Review and Agenda for Future Research. Journal of Organizational Behavior.

Reissner, Guenter & de Jong (2024). Exploring newcomer voice and silence dynamics: The role of organizational socialization. Journal of Occupational and Organizational Psychology.

Bouwens et al. (2025). Negative Feedback as a Necessary Evil: Unpacking the Role of the Organization's Social Context. Journal of Organizational Behavior.

Williams et al. (2025). Negative emotions, difficult conversations and leader–follower relationships. Journal of Occupational and Organizational Psychology.

Pin this graphic if you liked the post.

Kathrina Engelhardt shares strategic questions females in the workplace

should ask more often

 

Explore my coaching.

Next
Next

A Leadership Title Is Not a Mandate